THE WHITE TIGER BY ARAVIND ADIGA:-
To Buy the book click here
Generally we apply various theories to evaluate the texts, for
example Psycho-analysis, gender studies etc.
But here my focus is on "Redefining literature in context
of The White Tiger"-"whatever definition we try to give to literature
where this text falls in" ??
In literature, there is no totality of truth, but there are grains
of truth. Sometimes book shows us mirror image or/ & sometimes an X- ray image
of society. Reading literature is also a
quest for the self. We've to identify where am i in literature ?
Apart from this, there is age old debate since time of Plato
& Aristotle that poetry should be banned, because it makes people emotional.
so we've to study also from this angle that whether literature makes us emotional
or rational.
Another point is that of Art for art's sake and art for life's
sake. where this book falls in?
It would be appropriate to put here views of Bertolt Brecht-
"Art is not a mirror to reflect reality, but a hammer to shape it."
It is said in Sanskrit that "Sa vidya ya
vimuktaye". so we have to look from this point that Is Reading literature
leads us from darkness to light ?? Are we becoming free from shackles of narrow
minded mentality after reading book / literature
?? What happen to us ?? Does it make any difference after reading it ??
So, I have try to ponder this questions into The White Tiger.
"I was looking for the keys for years, but the door was
always open"-The White Tiger.
If you want to break the "MYTH OF SHINING INDIA"
&"MERA BHARAT MAHAN" read The White Tiger. There is not a single object
left out by Adiga. Whatever has come to his way, he has bluntly criticized it.
→ Corruption in politics & education, pollution,
prostitution, Hit & run, failure of governmental institution, Rich V/s poor
conflict,Religion, Capitalism V/s Marxism, Business model of India(entrepreneurs),
Globalization and changing morality,two sides of India-Darkness and Light
beautifully merged into single plot in humorous and satirical way.
From the beginning Balram satirizes various institutions of India.
He says ....."And our nation, though it has no drinking water, electricity,
sewage system, public transportation, sense of hygiene, discipline, courtesy or
punctuality, does have entrepreneurs."(P-4)
Then he criticizes gods of all the religion or we can say he
makes fun of habit of people to kiss arses of god or to pray god before beginning
of movie or starting other work. More than that he compares god with politicians.
Lets quote original lines :- "It's true that all these gods seems to do awfully
little work-much like our politicians-and yet keep winning re election to their
golden thrones, years after years. (P-8)
And more than that he says "....You will find an image of
a saffron coloured creature, half man half monkey: This is Hanuman, everybody's
favourite god in darkness. Do you know about Hanuman sir ? He was the faithful servant
of the god Rama, and we worship him in our temples because he is a shining example
of how to serve your masters with absolute fidelity, love and devotion. These are
the gods they have foisted on us, Mr Jiabao. Understand, now, how hard it is for
a man to win his freedom in India. (P-19)
Lets quote here words of Franz Kafka- "I think we ought
to read only the kinds of books that WOUND and STAB us. If the book we are reading
doesn't wake us up with a blow on the head, what are we reading it for?..... we
need the books that affect us like a disaster, that grieve us deeply, like the death
of someone we loved more than ourselves, like the death of someone we loved more
than ourselves, like a suicide. A book MUST BE THE AXE FOR THE FROZEN SEA INSIDE
US".
-Franz Kafka- Letter to Oskar Pollak ( 27 Jan. 1904)
This portion is exactly like an axe.
The White Tiger is an X- Ray image of a diseased body (Nation).
Even after taking X - Ray, if everything is fine within the body, then its no problem.
But here unfortunately, it is not the case. Everything is rotten, decayed inside.
And people are singing song of Shining India. But the truth is that large number
of people are left behind. This success story that are told again and again are
of very limited people.
Lets quote Adiga here....
"Well, this is the reality for a lot of Indian people and
it's important that it gets written about, rather than just hearing about the
5% of people in my country who are doing well. In somewhere like Bihar there
will be no doctors in the hospital. In northern India politics is so corrupt
that it makes a mockery of democracy. This is a country where the poor fear
tuberculosis, which kills 1,000 Indians a day, but people like me - middle- class
people with access to health services that are probably better than England's -
don't fear it at all. It's an unglamorous disease, like so much of the things
that the poor of India endure.
Here it is appropriate to compare with lines of Hamlet, "........rotten
state of Denmark"
BECAUSE...
Here in school teachers are selling uniform of students given
by government. why teachers do this ?? Because govt. dont pay them their salary
on time. and more shocking thing is that people sympathise them, they dont have
problem with it. so, when people see corruption happening around them and then even
if they remain silent? keep mum is even greater problem.
Lines about our school is very ironical that-"If the Indian
village is a paradise, then the school is a paradise within a paradise"(p-32).
"There was supposed to be a free food at my school- a government
programme gave every boy three rotis, yellow daal, and pickles at lunchtime. But
we never saw rotis, or yellow daal or pickles, and everybody knew why: the schoolteacher
had stolen our lunch money.(p-32/33).
The similar thing happens with hospitals also that there is no
doctor in hospital, he is in his own clinic or private hospitals. he can run clinic
by bribing officers.
"No!- Mr Jiabao, i urge you not to dip in the Ganga, unless
you want your mouth full of faeces, straw, soggy parts of human bodies, buffalo
carrion and seven different kinds of industrial acids. (p-15)
......in village buses were never late more than an hour or two!!!!(p.-23).
Inspector scolds teacher that- "There is no duster in this
class; there are no chairs; there are no uniforms for the boys. How much money have
you stolen from school funds ????(p-34)
So he says "Stories of rottenness and corruption are always
the best stories, arent they???(P-50) Because now people dont have problem with
it. We've naturalized it. accepted it. And this naturalization of corruption is
big problem.
At the same time he presents the picture of private hospitals
in Delhi that, "When i peeped in from
outside, the hospital's lobby looked as clean as the inside of the five star hotel."(P-180).
Failure of governmental institutions due to corruption or lack of political will
and widespread of privatization are also significant in the novel.
Mirror image is selective. Are we doing this?
HOW Far this image is true ??
Example of Gujarati cinema. lasvicious dialogue, witty
repartee etc in comedy of manners. The same in our cinema.
Lets discuss the example of Gujarati movie "Chello Divas".
This movie is praised a lot as a revival
of Gujarati cinema. But at the same time harshly criticized by many- they argue
that whatever is shown in the movie is not reality. All the students are not such
the way they have presented in the movie.
MY POINT IS THAT, ART IS (HAS TO BE) SELECTIVE. Whatever presented
/ narrated that may be half truth. But there is always other side of coin. One cant
generalize this as the only truth.
For example, so many experiences and observations about India
are ponder in The White Tiger. But India itself is so large and full of diversity.
Balram laughs at Democracy because of his experiences. that can be true to that
state or region. But it may not be the case is Gujrat or other states of country.
As a reader, while reading the novel i felt that "Novel
looks like tale about india of 1970-80(Even though it is 21st century text published
in 2008). Because i am born and brought up in Gujrat.And Gujrat is comparatively
developed state state then Bihar, U.P. or Jharkhand etc.Similarly the kind of traffic
jam or pollution which is in Delhi may not be in other parts of India. So i have
not seen the picture like this which books speaks about. But when we watch news
or read about other states of India it may have few similarities with the narrative
of the novel.
So, my point is that this mirror image is also sometimes problematic.
But at the same time one cant neglect it also.
Here we can apply Homi. K. Bhabha's - "Nation and Naration".
Nation - the Modern Janus.(Greek god with 2 face-looking forward
and backward). when one speaks other remains hidden.
Bhabha observes how other is created for Nation building. Other is always
fear in National identity. Story of shining India is one face of the Nation, where
as Balram's story of rottenness , of Darkness is the hidden face of the same Nation.
When entire world was
looking with hope towards India as a rising super power nation, and critics like Thomas Friedman were praising
India, at that time this novel came as a shock.
I may not believe the
representation of India, unless it is proved. The major incident in novel takes
place in Delhi - capital of India. While working as a driver Balram many time refers to traffic
jam and air pollution. is it true ? Do we have any scientific proof proving it
as truth?
In last Nov-Dec
(2015), There was a summit about climate change in France. According to
agency's report, most 150 polluted cities were identified from all over the
world. 15 cities of India were also mentioned there, and surprisingly Delhi was
top in list. This report came in 2015, but this problem discussed much earlier
novel in 2008.
Right now Odd &
Even formula started by Delhi govt. to control traffic and pollution. This step
also proves narrative as right.
Another significant
point is India of light & India of Darkness. In rural area people had no
work at all. People roam here &
there for work. Where as , as Balram mentions In Banglore there are
hoardings for job. Well qualified people are not available who can satisfy the
need of market.
Another interesting point
to observe is "Balram's metamorphosis from Edenic innocence to coldblooded
murderer. He was a good, loyal servant. But everywhere he saw evil and corruption
around him. Generally we saw that for example newly elected person in government
job are more honest and sincere but environment, work culture and atmosphere is
such that one has to sucumb to the situation. And later on he transforms into corrupt
officer ( as narrated in most of Hindi movies).
Similarly this reality is also presented in the novel, which can be read as x-ray
image of society. Balram as a driver was
living in very poor condition. Other drivers around him were also busy in cheap
magazines, prostitution, stealing petrol or black mailing their masters, selling
bottles of empty wine etc. This is bitter but reality.
When Ashok's wife left
him, he visited Ukranian girl with the Minister. This is the point where Balram
thinks "They corrupted him"(P-217). In Aristotelian term this can be said
as "Hamartia" -(Fatal flow:- A personality trait or
other characteristic of a real or fictional individual which
is immoral, destructive and which leads to
the ruin or profound suffering of that individual.) For
the character of Mr. Ashok.This gave strength to Balram that i am morally better
than my master. This is the strong cause for Balram to slit the throat of master.
while this incident, there
is a beautiful line that ".........India has progressed, hasn't it ?. She's (Ukranian girl student who is prostitute)
speaking in Hindi".
This passage attacks like
an axe on frozen snow. Actually, it laughs, makes mockery or fun of so called progress
and development.
She is a student, came
to study. But what is she doing???!!! What kind of education students are getting??
And she is visited by minsters and businessman,
the rich-super class people of India. If they are like this then what can we expect
from laymen???From Drivers to politicians this rottenness is spread like net everywhere.
Thats why i mentioned
this novel as a X- ray image of a diseased body (Nation). Nothing is well within.
It needs to cure as soon as possible.
Thats why it is said that
"sa vidya ya vimuktaye". So, i would like to categorize this novel under
category of "Art for Life's sake". Lets take example of "The Scarlet
Letter" by Nathaniel Hawthorne. When we read the novel we favor Hester Prynne,
even though she has commited adultery. Because literature always stands for humanity.But
imagine once, what will happen if everybody start doing what was done by Hester
? There will be chaos, anarchy in society. similarly as a reader we may feel sympathy
for Balram, but if everybody start doing like Balram then it will disturb the balance
of society. Because Adiga's vision is dystopic. Utopian society cant be created
with the dystopic vision like this. and this is what we've to learn from literature.After
studying text like this we've to learn that i shoudnt do this. Evil is not answer
to evil. Reading literature makes us free from shackles of narrowmindedness. It
gives vision to understand world in a better way.
Balram is not a hero for
me, but he is just Mouthpiece or representative of Majority of people living in
the era of Globalization , Capitalism and Privatization. As a writer Aravind captures
this under currunt of society. Slowly and steadily we are moving to become society
like this, where everybody wants success, richness, power. No matter what cost one
has to pay for it. Sliting Ashok's throat is example of it.
The demage which was not
done by hundreds of years of British raj, that damage is now being done by Neo Colonialism.
Balram was innocent in
village but transforms into murderer after entering into metro city.Cities stands
for (or is Metaphor for) L. P.G., Capitalism, MNC. it means he bacame murdere because
of all these things. Even more surprising / shocking thing is that he has no regret
for what he has done.
This is the morality with
which every child is growing in India that money is everything, and for success
you have to flow blood, whether yours or someone else's. There are only two destinies-to
eat or to be eaten up.
So, Adiga by capturing
the under currunt warning us against the direction towards which we are moving
as a society. So, again text is art for life's sake.
Balram says "I'm
man of action and change" (p-5).This point proves this book as it makes more
rational. Balram is a thinking man, but he thinks rationally. The way he reads god
Hanuman as a symbol of slavery is cleaarly anti dogmatic. He is not even emotionally
attached with his family. He dont sent money to his family on time. When he killed
Mr. Ashok in Delhi and ran away to Banglore, he knew very well that his family would
be killed by them, but he even dont care to inform the family member about the possible
danger.
And The White Tiger is
also not a fantasy but a critical and deep thinking about the India. It makes us
rational to think who we are ? What are our limitations and pitfalls as a society?
Rather than believing
into political speeches of "India is shining" and swaying with the flow
it makes us rational to question and doubt it.
it makes us rational to
ask why some one is so rich, living luxurious life in big houses, moving in cars
, at the same time other is so poor that they dont have even food to eat, home to
live, school to study or hospitals for basic health concerns ?
"Che garib na ghar
ma tel nu tipuy dohlyu, ane amiro ni kabar par ghee na diva bale che".
In Democratic society
where equality should prevail, Why this inequality, descrimination and class conflicts????
Someone is rich not only
because he is working hard but because other's share is stolen by them.
With the character of
Ram Persad- a driver who actually was muslim fellow but changed his name only to
get job, and Pinky madam- Ashok's wife who was christian, whom Balram calls a lady
with conscience- novel makes us rational to think that what is more important Religion
or humanity??? Why should we judge someone on the basis of religion?
Balram himself confesses
that Ram Persad was far better driver than him in every respect. Then even he has
to leave the job. Pinky was not accepted by Ashok's family because she belongs to
different religion.
As a reader we have to
think, what should be the criteria to judge the person?
*Conclusion:-
Thus, in an attempt to
redefining literature, i would like to conclude that the novel is an x- ray image,
it breaks the frozen snow within, it makes us rational and after all it is Art for
life's sake.
Work cited:-
Work cited:-
Adiga, Arvind. The White Tiger. New Delhi:
Harper collins, 2008.
www.theguardian.com. The
gardian. 2008. 10 01 2016
<www/theguardian.com/books/2008/oct/16/booker-prize>.
- To evaluate my assignment Click Here